Wednesday, June 9, 2010

Critical Animal Studies and the cocktail party test

Ian Bogost recently had a post about self-branding and doing interdisciplinary work. The first suggestion was to have a name for the work you do. It is in that mode that I have embraced the term critical animal studies. Now, I recognize that to some degree it is a non-sense phrase, but the ambiguity seems necessary at this point to make a large enough tent. Though I tend to share Craig's mistrust of the over use of the term critical, I find the term critical tends to decrease confusion from the phrase animal studies (which tends to lead people to think I do ethology or something of the sort). Regardless, I usually tell people I study philosophy, so the name isn't such a big deal.

The real problem with the cocktail party (which I've almost never been to, so I use this to mean any light conversation gathering with mostly strangers) discussion is you can't tell people you are writing a dissertation in philosophy without them asking what the dissertation is on. Now, the problem isn't that I cannot describe my work to non-philosophers, even non-academics. This is when I am jealous of Bogost and wish I could say I was working on video games. The problem is that my work is naturally polarizing. And the point of cocktail parties is to keep things light, fun, and happy. Not focusing on massive forms of violence that we are all complacent in, and a good chance the person I am talking to is invested in denying that violence. Now, that means I either need to mislead the person about what I do ("I work on the distinction between humans and other animals"), or I try to tell them what I do in broad strokes that aren't as controversial ("Factory farms are bad, mmkay").
Ultimately my problems aren't like what most interdisciplinary people have. The real problem is the controversy and sadness that surrounds my work once people actually figure out what I do.

Tuesday, June 8, 2010

Bennett, Ch. 4

I don't have much to say on this chapter. I'm glad it begins off with her admitting that many of the properties we once thought to be slowly human also belongs to other animals. I would have liked to see what this insight makes her feel in relation to the previous chapter on edible matter. Though none of that surprises anyone, I am sure.

The rest of the chapter is well-taken. While few of us are metal workers, I am sure we have all had the experience in pottery, or bread baking, or what have you, of the substance we felt of as inert takes on its own generative properties and force. But how do we tie together this almost pantheistic vitalism, in which everything has force, with the affirmation of a life or the life from outside that Deleuze was so fond of speaking of. If you turn to Deleuze's book on Foucault, in the chapter "Strategies and the Non-stratified", you will see Deleuze speak of certain thought of life that comes from the outside, and that does not belong to any species. In the same chapter you will see he talk of the necessary human life, the power particular to human life. My concern here, and I have spoken of this before, is a fear that a notion of a general materialist vitalism might dismantle anthropocentrism while maintaining humanism. And it is this book's relationship to humanism that I continue to wonder about.

Also, if this blog was the type to post pictures, I would have a picture of Wolverine or Weapon X, something like that in honor of the discussion of adamantine.

Monday, June 7, 2010

A Post of Links

I leave for GA tomorrow for my sister's wedding. Blogging will be light to non-existent while I'm gone.

Ben is up with his post on chapter 4 on Vibrant Matter. I wish he'd expand his critical comments, because I am interested, but I am unclear what he is arguing for. Regardless, looking forward to his comments on the next chapter.

William Gibson has mostly given up blogging to embrace twitter, but this blog post on future fatigue is wonderful. It is smart and somewhat rambling. It stands firm against teleology and utopianism (an interesting stance for a sci-fi writer, which he gets into somewhat). It also has this little gem:
The synthetic genome, arguably artificial life, was somehow less amazing. The sort of thing one feels might already have been achieved, somehow. Triggering the “Oh, yeah” module. “Artificial life? Oh, yeah.”

Though these scientists also inserted a line of James Joyce’s prose into their genome. That triggers a sense of the surreal, in me at least. They did it to incorporate a yardstick for the ongoing measurement of mutation. So James Joyce’s prose is now being very slowly pummelled into incoherence by cosmic rays.


Ian Bogost recently had an interesting post on self-branding when you do interdisciplinary work. Very interesting, and I had hoped to get around to writing a blog post about the differences of how these conversations go when you work on video games, versus when you work on something that is immediately polarizing.


Most of you seemed to really enjoy the link to Feminist Hulk. Well, just in case you missed it. Feminist Hulk has a delightful interview with Ms. Magazine. Well worth the read.


I've recently been finding and trying to figure out the best version of "St. James Infirmary Blues". Long one of my favorite songs, I have no doubt this has been inspired by how much I have enjoyed watching Treme. Right now, Snooks Eaglin has been winning the battle of the best (sung) version.

Sunday, June 6, 2010

One last one on Bennett

I'd leave this for Ben, but because it seems mostly inspired by one of the chapters I did, I'll go ahead and post this one here. This comes from the blog The Electrate Professor. I'll post most of it here, but please click the link to read the rest.

I was immediately struck by Bennett’s description of her philosophical project on the first page of the preface as an attempt “to think slowly an idea that runs fast through modern heads: the idea of matter as passive stuff” (vii). This immediately made me think of De Landa’s reference to glass as a slow-moving fluid, one that takes centuries to flow. Deleuze and Guattari often engage the phenomenon of speed as a way to indicate degrees of difference: “Speed turns the point into a line.” Her chapter on “Edible Matter” references the slow food movement, which I used to conceive of “the slow thought movement.”

So how does one think slowly? Perhaps it is as easy as paying more attention. In the words of one aphorism, “a thing is simple or complex, depending on how much attention one pays it.” Slow thinking would suggest the kind of attention to historical process that De Landa makes famous in his A Thousand Years of Nonlinear History, a book that Bennett uses (among others) to frame her argument in chapter one.

Perhaps the claim to a vitality intrinsic to matter itself becomes more plausible if one takes a long view of time. If one adopts the perspective of evolutionary rather than biographical time, for example, a mineral efficacy becomes visible. (10-11)

She then provides a long example of such mineral efficacy from De Landa’s book, a quote which is worth repeating here since it’s so interesting:

Soft tissue (gels and aerosols, muscle and nerve) reigned supreme until 5000 million years ago. At that point, some of the conglomerations of fleshy matter-energy that made up life underwent a sudden mineralization, and a new material for constructing living creatures emerged: bone. It is almost as if the mineral world that had served as a substratum for the emergence of biological creatures was reasserting itself” (11, quoting Nonlinear History p. 26).

She also quotes Adorno at one point, who writes, “What we may call the thing itself is not positively and immediately at hand. He who wants to know it must think more, not less” (13). This “thinking more,” I believe, is enhanced by “the long view of time” Bennett mentions. Slow thinking allows for a sedimentation, a layering of processes and matter-energy flows that make up the complex expression of the here-and-now (or the wherever-and-whenever we happen to be attending to).

Bennett’s discusses Adorno’s “negative dialectics” as a way to “become more cognizant that conceptualization automatically obscures the inadequacy of its concepts,” at one point quoting him as saying, “objects do not go into their concepts without leaving a remainder” (14, emphasis mine). I wondered here again about the possibility of a different way of thinking, along the lines developed in a previous blog post trying to think beyond the concept. Perhaps there’s something here that would allow me to develop the idea of “the incept” as a way in to an object, a kind of “becoming-thought-object,” a thinking-with or -through an object. Such inceptual thinking would require a slowing down, a kind of phase-alignment of one’s own energy with the objects under observation (for her it was the debris that “provoked affects in me” [4]).

Saturday, June 5, 2010

Bennett's Vibrant Matter so far, moving on to Naught Thought

I've enjoyed hosting this week's discussion of Bennett's Vibrant Matter. Starting tomorrow we move on to Ben's place at Naught Thought.

If you want to see the first week's posts, please check out Philosophy in a Time of Terror.

Here is my precis on chapter 2, and here is my commentary on chapter 2.

Here is my precis on chapter 3, and here is my commentary on chapter 3.

Here is Adrian Ivakhiv on chapters 2&3.

And here is Ben Woodard on the book so far.

Update: The Electrate Professor has a post up here on the book so far (mostly chapter 3).

Friday, June 4, 2010

Philosophically evil animated kid's movie

I recently watched Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths (let's skip why) and normally this event would not be blog worthy. After all, it is a rather intolerable film, with a mediocre script, so-so voice acting, and absurdly long animated action sequences that made little sense. But if you are looking for a movie for a child the age to enjoy such things it is on watch now for netflix. But here is the thing, the main villain is inspired by some sort of existentialist/nihilistic philosophy. The rest of this post is going to contain spoilers, such as they are. You might, possibly, want to stop reading.

The movie makes use of a strong version of multiple worlds theory (the second laziest and most incoherent sci-fi device, lead only by time travel), the sort that claims that every little action produces several different worlds. So, in this story a villain known as Owlman (a evil version of Batman), is part of a gang of superpowered thugs who have developed a doomsday device called the Quantum Eigenstate Device (or as it is always referred to, The QED). The supervillain gang thinks this device is going to be used to blackmail their world, but really Owlman has a different plan. He is haunted by some trauma from his past, and broods on the fact that the notion of the multiverse means no action can ever have any sort of meaning. Because no matter what happens, everything happens. But, somewhere exists an Earth Prime, and if that planet is destroyed, then the entire multiverse can be destroyed. So, Owlman is possessed by the desire to commit the only action that can possibly have any meaning, the destruction of the whole multiverse. I have to admit, I really enjoyed the philosophical justification for his villainy. That part was pretty good for a direct to DVD kids movie.

Thursday, June 3, 2010

A Post of Links

Anthony Paul Smith and Daniel Whistler have a new edited volume out that looks to be exciting: After the Postsecular and the Postmodern: New Essays in Continental Philosophy of Religion. This very well could be the first of many more posts on this new work.

EJ has a draft up on his paper about Judith Butler and animals. It is entitled "Species Trouble", good title. Highly suggested read.

The UN says we need to move away from a diet of animal products, or else. As Erik Marcus points out, they never mention the words vegetarian or vegan.

I recently said something supportive of Michael Pollan, time to push back. He recently bashed feminists (again). As my brother aptly put it, this is just another piece of proof that for people like Pollan and Salatin this is fundamentally a conservative movement in liberal drag.

This Onion video about apes facing their mortality is truly funny. Though my guess is apes already know they are one day going to die.

And the best thing on the internet these days is Butler inspired feminist Hulk twitter feed. (h/t Feminist Philosophers) Here is an example:
HULK SMASH MASTER'S HOUSE! THEN HULK MELT DOWN MASTER'S TOOLS AND USE METAL TO MAKE ADORABLE LITTLE BASKET TO HANG ON FRONT OF HULK BIKE.

And another one:
HULK USE ALL-CAPS. HULK CHOOSE NOT TO IMPOSE HIERARCHY ON LANGUAGE. PLUS, BIG HULK FINGERS MAKE SHIFT-KEY PROBLEMATIC.

How can anyone not love that?

This post of links' music comes from my favorite album of 2009, Dead Man's Bones. This project was originally intended as a supernatural children's musical, and those roots are pretty obvious in the album it eventually became. Also, who knew that Ryan Gosling had such a super sexy singing voice? Here is "Lose Your Soul"