Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Animal Capacity and Vulnerability.

First an announcement: The interblog reading group on Bennett's Vibrant Matter is putting together the finishing touches on the schedule, but the key thing is that the discussion is likely to begin the week of the 22nd-29th. So, if you want to be following along at home --and you know you want to-- that should give you enough time to pick up the book. Now on to the post:

When it is time to write about the changing attitudes towards animals that is emerging, I think special attention will have to be paid to youtube (and online videos in general). It is one thing for science to talk about the capacities of certain animals, and even for you to know about it, and another to see an elephant painting a picture. As a matter of fact, watching youtube videos of animals have even become a methodology of scientific research (and oh yeah, some animals can dance to a beat as well). In short, what the constant stream of animal videos are doing is affectively proving to many us that everything we thought we knew about what divided the human from all other living beings-- THE animal-- is wrong. We are learning that the multiplicity of other animals are both more alien from us and more alike to us than we had originally believed. That is why it is always so interesting when we find out beavers have created a structure big enough to be seen from space or that chimps make and use tools (sorry Stiegler), and there is of course an youtube video of those chimps as well. All of this goes to support what Derrida claimed in Rogues, namely:
Although I cannot demonstrate this here, I believe– and the stakes are becoming more and more urgent– that none of the conventionally accepted limits between the so-called human living being and the so-called animal one, none of the oppositions, none of the supposedly linear and indivisible boundaries, resist a rational deconstruction– whether we are talking about language, culture, social symbolic networks, technicity or work, even the relationship to death and to mourning, and even the prohibition against or avoidance of incest– so many ‘capacities’ of which the ‘animal’ (a general singular noun!) is said so dogmatically to be bereft, impoverished (p. 151).
What is at stake here is what Derrida has frequently called the 'propers of Man', those capacities that Man believed she alone had access to. It is a system of anthropocentrism that is destabilized by all of these animal capacities. This focus on animal capacity or generally anti-anthropocentric capacity, however, seems to contradict another important theoretical development in the political, ethical, and ontological domains of animal philosophy: namely the focused on a shared sense of vulnerability.
This notion of vulnerability is found in thinkers as similar yet diverse as Jacques Derrida, Judith Butler, Cora Diamond, Cary Wolfe, and to some degree in Jean-Luc Nancy and his notion of exposure. It is a concept I have found particularly useful (you can see some of my public work on this here and here), and I am sure many other young scholars have as well. The concept of vulnerability seeks to reorient our philosophical commitments away from what we can do and more to our sense of precariousness or finitude (as an aside, in the back of my mind has been the thought that thinking vulnerability alongside Bruno Latour's notion of trial by strength, but it hasn't gone anywhere yet). Therefore, a focus on animal capacity seems to contradict (or at least is rendered to a mere curiosity by) the commitment to vulnerability. Indeed, Cora Diamond has remarked that the moral basis of vegetarianism is endangered by arguments that seek to confuse the boundary lines between the human animal and the non-human animal.
Now, I haven't been able to work through this seeming contradiction, but my gut impulse is that it isn't a contradiction, of if it is, it is a necessary one. Regardless, my thoughts are that both projects are important, and it is only by being brought in explicit dialogue with each other that either stand a chance of being more successfully forwarded.

Update:
Peter definitely puts my aside on Latour far more clearly than I did:

Friday, May 7, 2010

Vibrant Matter

I finally got my copy of Jane Bennett's Vibrant Matter. First, no one told me that there was a chapter on "Edible Matter." *Looks accusatory at the entire academic blogosphere*.
Second, the book itself is physically quite appealing. This is the second book from Duke press that I came across that is really beautifully put together. The first one being Ed Cohen's A Body Worth Defending (thanks Steph). There is also a third important recent Duke press book, Rodolfo Kusch's Indigenous and Popular Thinking in América, but this one doesn't have same physical presence (though intellectually still up to par).
Finally, I am very excited about the reading group.

Wednesday, May 5, 2010

Summer reading group

Adrian has suggested an interblog reading group on Bennett's Vibrant Matter and Morton's The Ecological Thought. Peter is down, and I am down for both, as well. If other people are interested, hopefully they will speak up. And then shortly a reading schedule and starting. I want an excuse to read both of these books, and talking about them seems like an added benefit.

Oh, speaking of books to read, my review of Cary Wolfe's What is Posthumanism? should be up later this week or next week. The very, very short version: It's worth reading.

Tuesday, May 4, 2010

Opposition to Localvorism

The new issues of the Journal of Critical Animal Studies is out. The whole thing is worth reading, but I want to suggest reading the article "'Green' Eggs and Ham?" (pdf). The article is written by Vasile Stanescu (full disclosure, we're brothers), and is rigorous examination of the politics and principles of the localvore movement. Moreover, it is also something of an expose of the secret conservative nature of the intellectual founders of localvorism. I highly suggest this for anyone interested in localvorism, vegetarianism and veganism, and current food issues.

Monday, May 3, 2010

Your first Amazon purchase?

Megan McArdle has a good meme, go to your amazon.com order page, and post what was the first thing you bought.

Well, for me, it was Jan. 2003, and I bought Zone 6: Incorporations, edited by Crary and Kwinter. Which is still a very interesting selection, and was great for where I was (uhm, for those that don't my age, this would have been my junior year as an undergrad).

Saturday, May 1, 2010

Can we give up the term postmodernism?

It wasn't a particularly useful term to begin with, but at least in the 80s and 90s there were still people who self identified with this term. But at this point, anytime someone uses the term postmodernism all I know is that they are trying to smear/attack some philosophical group. And if a term is only used as a smear term, and is basically only used as a strawman, can we just agree to drop it?

But yeah, you really do have to read Heidegger if you want to understand Derrida

Without a doubt, probably the funniest video I have ever seen:


(h/t Adam)

I also wanted to suggest this new post by Levi on ideology. I am working on a longer response, but just in case I don't follow through, you should go read it. Really short version: (1) I mostly agree, and (2) Isn't it funny that he is engaging in ideology critique with those that engage exclusively or primarily in ideology critique? (and I don't mean intellectually weak or contradictory, I just mean humorous).